China's legal sector eyes APEC to widen online dispute resolution

Source:China Daily

2026年11月21日China Daily

大字 小字

Separated by thousands of miles, with the buyer based in an Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation economy without an office on the Chinese mainland and the supplier's management frequently on the move, resolving a dispute over undelivered goods seemed daunting.

However, when the case went to mediation, APEC's online dispute resolution, or ODR, mechanism made distance a non-issue.

Facilitated by the Shanghai Hongkou District People's Court and the North Bund Alternative Dispute Resolution Center, the parties negotiated under the APEC Collaborative Framework for ODR of Cross-Border B2B Disputes, which was endorsed by the APEC Economic Committee in 2019 and implemented in 2022.

After the parties reached a mediated settlement in September, the entire process, from signing the online mediation agreement to serving the electronic ruling, took just three hours.

The court will continue to enhance its multi-tiered dispute resolution mechanism in cooperation with NBADR, said Ye Weiwei, president of the Shanghai Hongkou District People's Court.

These efforts aim to provide exemplary international legal services to domestic and overseas litigants alike and strengthen the local business environment through the rule of law, Ye said.

The experience extends beyond Shanghai. Seven APEC economies have so far opted in to the Collaborative Framework, including China and Hong Kong, China. APEC lists eight ODR service providers, including Shanghai-based NBADR and eBRAM International Online Dispute Resolution Centre, the only Hong Kong-based provider on the list.

SMEs in need

Growing trade between China and other APEC economies underscores the need for ODR services to help businesses on both sides resolve commercial disputes.

According to Chinese customs data, China's imports and exports with other APEC economies rose 23.9 percent year-on-year to 24.07 trillion yuan ($3.6 trillion) in the first three quarters of this year, accounting for 60.3 percent of its total foreign trade.

Compared with large companies, smaller businesses have more at stake when cross-border transactions go wrong. Concerns that they may not be able to afford to pursue claims when deals fall through have likely deterred some from venturing into overseas markets, said Ronald Sum Kwan-ngai, eBRAM's vice-chairman.

Micro-, small and medium-sized enterprises account for more than 97 percent of businesses across the 21 APEC economies but contribute 35 percent or less of direct exports, according to data from APEC's SME Working Group.

Hong Kong's ODR edge

Sum said Hong Kong's ODR platforms are making dispute resolution easier and less costly through the established use of high-definition video, real-time transcription and AI-powered multilingual translation.

The city's diverse pool of professionals also gives businesses worldwide access to arbitrators and mediators familiar with their languages and commercial cultures, he added.

Nicholas Chan Hiu-fung, director of the Asian-African Legal Consultative Organization Hong Kong Regional Arbitration Centre, described Hong Kong as a "transit hub for legal systems", where the common law and commercial practices familiar to international businesses meet the mainland market and Asian business culture.

The Hong Kong-headquartered International Organization for Mediation, which became operational in October 2025, has further expanded the city's potential to develop its international mediation services, Chan said.

Chan hopes IOMed will facilitate exchanges and training and develop model clauses to improve compatibility among the rules of different economies.

He said his team is drafting a model clause requiring parties to attempt mediation before proceeding to arbitration, with plans to release it at a related forum this month. Under the proposed clause, disputes would first be referred to IOMed for mediation. If no settlement is reached within 45 days, the case would be referred to the AALCO Hong Kong Regional Arbitration Centre for arbitration.

Agreeing that Hong Kong has an edge in ODR, Alex Fan Hoi-kit, president of the Hainan International Arbitration Court, said the SAR is well positioned to help businesses in China and overseas resolve cross-border disputes.

Its international legal services, specialist talent and legal technology, backed by mutual legal assistance arrangements with the mainland, can help businesses overcome language barriers and navigate different legal systems while reducing the difficulties caused by geographical distance, Fan said.

For arbitration, Hong Kong's access to mainland legal support offers an additional advantage, said Fan, who practices in both the mainland and the SAR. Under an arrangement that took effect on Oct 1, 2019, parties to Hong Kong-seated arbitrations administered by designated institutions can apply to mainland courts for interim measures, including the preservation of property and evidence.

To deepen cooperation, Fan suggested that Hong Kong and the mainland adopt a phased approach. They could begin with joint training and professional exchanges, move on to aligning guidelines for electronic service, evidence and remote hearings, and eventually pursue cross-border integration of ODR systems.

APEC spurs outreach

With China hosting APEC meetings this year, Chan called on legal professionals to seize the opportunity to raise regional businesses' awareness of ODR services and encourage them to incorporate such mechanisms into their cross-border trade risk management.

He hopes authorities and legal practitioners in the SAR and on the mainland will jointly reach out to political and business leaders gathering for APEC.

Chan proposed organizing a Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area legal forum for APEC business leaders, accompanied by delegation visits to Shenzhen and Hong Kong.

Delegates could first explore Shenzhen's innovation ecosystem and manufacturing supply chains before visiting IOMed, Hong Kong's legal infrastructure and its ODR platforms to learn how these services can support industrial cooperation and risk management.

Sum is among those planning to take action. He said he intends to actively participate in this year's APEC-related events to introduce Hong Kong's and the wider Greater Bay Area's dispute resolution services to more regional businesses. This will include discussions with Southeast Asian institutions on potential partnerships to share mediator and arbitrator resources.

Such gatherings also allow service providers to gain firsthand insights into the needs of different economies through exchanges and tailor their services accordingly, Sum added.

To encourage wider adoption of ODR, Fan suggested that businesses incorporate relevant clauses into their commercial contracts when signing deals.

Chan agreed, saying such clauses give parties a clear dispute resolution pathway from the outset.

"What many such businesses want is to settle their differences through negotiation and keep doing business," Sum said.

When online resolution enables companies to protect their rights at an affordable cost while preserving business relationships, its value extends beyond the contract at hand, he added. It also leaves the door open for the next deal.

Editor:Zhou Jinmiao

×